Insurance Expert Witness

Insurance Expert Witness Services

Independent expert opinion for insurers, panel solicitors, loss adjusters and claims teams on quantum, professional practice in negligence claims, building surveying, structural engineering and delay.

30+ years

Construction industry
experience

MRICS

Chartered Quantity
Surveyor

MCIArb

Member, Chartered Institute
of Arbitrators

CPR Part 35

Litigation expert evidence
Expert Disciplines

Areas of Independent Expert Opinion

Appointments are matched to the discipline and issues in dispute.

Quantum Expert Witness

Independent Opinion on Remedial Cost and Quantum

Expert opinion on disputed repair and reinstatement costs, valuation, remedial works, damages and other construction quantum issues.

Quantity Surveying Professional Practice in Negligence Claims

Independent Opinion on Quantity Surveying Practice

Expert opinion on allegations involving quantity surveying, valuation, payment assessment, cost advice, certification and contract administration.

Building Surveying Expert Witness

Independent Opinion on Building Condition, Defects and Remedial Scope

Expert opinion on building defects, damage, condition, the technical cause of defects or damage within the surveyor's expertise, repair requirements and schedules of remedial work.

Structural & Civil Engineering Expert Witness

Independent Opinion on Structural Damage, Technical Cause and Remedial Engineering

Expert opinion on structural damage, failure, movement, loading, structural adequacy, the technical causes of damage or failure, and remedial engineering issues involving buildings and infrastructure.

Delay & Disruption Expert Witness

Independent Opinion on Delay and Programme Effects

Expert opinion on delay, critical path, programme impact, delay causation, concurrency and disruption where these issues arise from insured events, remedial works or related disputes.

SELECTED MATTERS

Insurance Expert Witness Case Studies

These matters are examples of ICRS appointments in this area. Each case summarises the issue, ICRS's involvement, the work delivered and the outcome.

Case study

Project Monitoring Surveyor Expert Reports in a Professional Negligence Claim

The reports provided independent expert opinion on the Project Monitoring Surveyor's appointed services and professional performance. The professional negligence claim remains ongoing.

Client
Development finance lender
Issue
A professional negligence claim concerned the performance of an appointed Project Monitoring Surveyor across two residential development projects.
Case study

Roadway Reinstatement Quantum Expert Report

The report provided the Court and the parties with independent quantum evidence on the reinstatement scope and cost.

Client
Parties to civil proceedings under a joint instruction
Issue
A dispute concerned the effect of groundworks on a private roadway and adjoining land, together with the cost of any required reinstatement.
Case study

Quantity Surveying Expert Report in a Professional Negligence Claim

The report provided independent expert opinion on the consultant's professional performance, payment administration and the relationship between those matters and the subsequent adjudication and settlement.

Client
Employer on a mixed use development
Issue
A professional negligence claim concerned the administration of an interim payment application by the appointed Employer's Agent and Quantity Surveyor.
Insurance Claims and Disputes

When Expert Evidence Is Required

Insurance claims can become technically or financially disputed where the parties disagree about the technical cause of damage, remedial scope, reasonable cost or the professional services provided.

ICRS provides independent expert opinion within the appointed expert’s professional discipline.

Property and Infrastructure Damage

Expert evidence may be required where a dispute concerns:

  • Damage to residential, commercial or industrial property
  • Damage to bridges, roads and other infrastructure
  • Cause of physical damage
  • Structural damage or failure
  • Required remedial works
  • Reasonable repair or reinstatement costs
  • Disputed contractor quotations or valuations
  • Third-party property damage
  • Technical or quantum issues in subrogated recovery claims
  • Technical or quantum issues in claims against an insured party

Professional Indemnity Claims

Expert evidence may also be required where allegations concern the professional services of:

  • Quantity surveyors
  • Contract administrators
  • Building surveyors
  • Structural or civil engineers
  • Other construction professionals within the appointed expert’s discipline

Typical issues include:

  • Professional practice, valuation, certification, cost advice, contract administration, inspection, technical advice and alleged acts or omissions.

ICRS provides independent opinion within the appointed expert's professional discipline. Questions of insurance policy coverage, legal liability and legal advice remain matters for the parties, their legal advisers and the court or tribunal.

Preliminary and Formal Evidence

From Preliminary Opinion to Formal Expert Evidence

Not every matter requires a CPR Part 35 report at the outset.

Preliminary Expert Opinion

Insurers, solicitors and claims professionals may require an initial independent assessment before deciding how a claim should proceed.

This may include:

  • Desktop review
  • Preliminary quantum assessment
  • Initial opinion on professional practice and alleged acts or omissions
  • Review of remedial costs
  • Review of technical evidence
  • Identification of further evidence or specialist disciplines required

Formal Expert Evidence

Where the matter proceeds to litigation or another formal dispute process, the appointment may include:

This may include:

  • CPR Part 35 expert reports
  • Arbitration or adjudication expert reports
  • Responses to expert questions
  • Review of opposing expert evidence
  • Experts’ meetings
  • Joint statements
  • Conferences with solicitors and counsel
  • Oral evidence
Instructing ICRS

What Happens After an Enquiry?

  1. Conflict and Discipline Check

    We review the parties, nature of the dispute and expert discipline required. We identify whether the matter falls within an ICRS expert’s professional expertise and carry out the initial conflict check.

  2. CV, Availability and Fee

    Where the matter is suitable, we provide the proposed expert’s CV together with availability and appropriate fee information.

  3. Instructions and Expert Evidence

    Following formal instruction, the expert reviews the relevant material and provides independent opinion on the defined issues within their discipline.

ICRS Consult

Independent Expertise for Insurance Disputes

ICRS provides independent expert opinion on construction, property and infrastructure matters.

Our experts act within defined professional disciplines and provide evidence based on the records, methodology and technical issues relevant to the instruction.

  • Insurance claims
  • Professional indemnity claims
  • Subrogated recoveries
  • Third-party damage claims
  • Property damage disputes
  • Construction and infrastructure damage
  • Litigation
  • Arbitration
  • Adjudication

Discuss an Insurance Expert Appointment

If you are looking for an expert, send us the parties, discipline required, relevant deadline and a short summary of the issues.

The initial discussion is free of charge.

Insurance Expert Witness Services

Send Us Your Details

Name, email and a few lines about the issue is enough to start. We will come back to you within 24 hours.